| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| Alphonse Capone, No. 1 | Win as Alphonse Capone. | Silver
|
| Angelo Genna, No. 1 | Win as Angelo Genna. | Silver
|
| Bulletproof | Finish the game without getting anyone in your crew killed. | Gold
|
| Bullseye | Take down an enemy with a single shot. | Bronze
|
| Closed Casket | Kill Daniel McKee Jackson. | Bronze
|
| Curtain Call | Kill Goldie Garneau. | Bronze
|
| Daniel McKee Jackson, No. 1 | Win as Daniel McKee Jackson. | Silver
|
| Dean O'Banion, No. 1 | Win as Dean O'Banion. | Silver
|
| Elvira Duarte, No. 1 | Win as Elvira Duarte. | Silver
|
| Flor de Muerto | Kill Elvira Duarte. | Bronze
|
| Frank Ragen, No. 1 | Win as Frank Ragen. | Silver
|
| Frankie Donovan, No. 1 | Win as Frankie Donovan. | Silver
|
| Goldie Garneau, No. 1 | Win as Goldie Garneau. | Silver
|
| I Know A Guy | Hire a gangster of each profession. | Bronze
|
| I'll Be Back | Have someone in your crew go to jail. | Bronze
|
| I've Got Your Back | Form a Business Arrangement. | Bronze
|
| Into the Sunset | Kill Salazar Reyna. | Bronze
|
| It's just Business | Kill Frank Ragen. | Bronze
|
| Jack of All Trades, Master of None | Own five of each racket type. | Bronze
|
| Joseph Saltis, No. 1 | Win as Joseph Saltis. | Silver
|
| Last Call | Kill Joseph Saltis. | Bronze
|
| Let This Be A Warning | Perform an execution. | Bronze
|
| Like Shootin' Ducks in a Pond | Kill Sai Wing Mock. | Bronze
|
| Lone Wolf | Finish the game without recruiting a gangster. | Gold
|
| Luck of the Draw | Kill Stephanie St. Clair. | Bronze
|
| Mabel Ryley, No. 1 | Win as Mabel Ryley. | Silver
|
| Maggie Dyer, No. 1 | Win as Maggie Dyer. | Silver
|
| Maximizer | Get a hotel and have all synergies simultaneously. | Silver
|
| My Specialty | Get a synergy bonus. | Bronze
|
| On My Own | Complete the tutorial. | Bronze
|
| Overachiever | Collect all trophies. | Platinum
|
| Public Enemy 1 | Became Enemy of the State while maintaining the highest notoriety. | Bronze
|
| Pushing Daisies | Kill Dean O'Banion. | Bronze
|
| Reliable | Max the loyalty of one member of your crew. | Bronze
|
| Sai Wing Mock, No. 1 | Win as Sai Wing Mock. | Silver
|
| Salazar Reyna, No. 1 | Win as Salazar Reyna. | Silver
|
| Shoulda stayed in Sicily | Kill Angelo Genna. | Bronze
|
| Stephanie St. Clair, No. 1 | Win as Stephanie St. Clair. | Silver
|
| The Ice Queen Go-eth | Kill Mabel Ryley. | Bronze
|
| The Irish Goodbye | Kill Frankie Donovan. | Bronze
|
| The Lion Sleeps Tonight | Kill Maggie Dyer. | Bronze
|
| There Goes the Neighborhood | Took over a neighborhood. | Bronze
|
| This Never Happened | Bribe a cop. | Bronze
|
| Trust Me | Land a hit with 10% or lower odds. | Bronze
|
| Whacked | Kill Ronnie O'Neill. | Bronze
|
| You Know Who I Am | Kill Alphonse Capone. | Bronze
|