| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| 2 Outta 3 Ain't Bad | Complete every Challenge in the 2 out of 3 Falls Tier | Bronze
|
| 5 Star Has Landed! | Successfully perform any Finisher during a match | Bronze
|
| A Hearty Congratulations | Complete every Challenge in the Gregg Hearty Tier | Bronze
|
| All Charged Up | Complete ALL Supercharged Objectives Challenge Mode | Bronze
|
| Anything Goes | Complete every Challenge in the No Holds Barred Tier | Bronze
|
| Anytime, Anywhere | Complete every Challenge in the Falls Count Anywhere Tier | Bronze
|
| Big Boss Men | Win a Main Event Challenge match | Silver
|
| Blacksmith | Win an Exhibition Match with your head in red level damage | Silver
|
| Boom Goes the Dynamite! | Complete every Challenge in the Dynamite Pegasus Tier | Bronze
|
| Boom! | Perform a Finisher Reversal during a match | Silver
|
| Cash is King! | Unlock an in-game feature in the 5 Star Wrestling Shop | Silver
|
| Challenge Accepted! | Win a Challenge Match | Bronze
|
| Chess Master | Trigger a Move Fail by working your opponents legs until he can't execute lift up moves anymore | Bronze
|
| Cocky | Perform both Taunts available to your wrestler in one match | Bronze
|
| Completionist | Complete every Objective in Challenge Mode in 5 Star Wrestling | Silver
|
| Crimson Mask | Complete every Challenge in the First Blood Tier | Bronze
|
| Davie vs. Goliath | Defeat a Brute as a Risk Taker | Silver
|
| Double the Risk | Perform back-to-back Quick Finishing moves | Bronze
|
| Electric | Complete every Challenge in the Jonny Miavia Tier | Bronze
|
| Every Time a Bell Rings... | Playing as Curtis Angel, defeat Dynamite Pegasus and don't allow him to use his Finisher | Silver
|
| From Outta Somewhere! | Playing as Andy Organ, defeat Jonny Miavia and don't allow him to use his Finisher | Silver
|
| Gassed | Perform a Tired Finishing move during a match | Bronze
|
| Get Up, Stand Up | Complete every Challenge in the Last Man Standing Tier | Bronze
|
| I'm a Survivor | Complete ALL Survival Objectives in Challenge Mode | Bronze
|
| Ice Capped | Perform every one of Icebergs Finishers | Bronze
|
| Once If You're Lucky! | Perform any Corner Finishing move | Bronze
|
| Pin to Win | Complete every Challenge in the Pinfall Only Tier | Bronze
|
| Power Plant | Perform a Strong Finishing move during a match | Bronze
|
| Quicker Than A Hiccup | Complete ALL Time Objectives in Challenge Mode | Bronze
|
| Ready To Rage! | Complete every Challenge in the Andy Organ Tier | Bronze
|
| Rising Star | Win an Exhibition Match | Bronze
|
| Seek & Destroy | Complete ALL Seek & Destroy Objectives in Challenge Mode | Bronze
|
| Star Performer | Earn all Trophies | Platinum
|
| Stars are Better than Medals! | Complete every Challenge in the Curtis Angel Tier | Bronze
|
| Swerved | Perform a Reversal during a match | Bronze
|
| Terminator | Complete every Challenge in the HarVee Dee Tier | Bronze
|
| The Comeback Kid | Complete ALL Comeback Objectives in Challenge Mode | Bronze
|
| The Conqueror | Complete every Challenge in the Ragnabrök Tier | Bronze
|
| The Decider | Receive a 5 Star Rating for a match between two Rivals | Silver
|
| The Perfect Example | Get a 5 Star Rating and win in a Challenge Match | Bronze
|
| They Tapped Out! | Complete every Challenge in the Submission Tier | Bronze
|
| This Is Awesome! | Receive a 5 Star Rating in a Player vs Player match | Gold
|
| This Is Wrestling! | Complete every Challenge in the Wrestling Tier | Bronze
|
| Time to Die! | Perform a Wake-up Taunt followed by a Finisher during a match | Silver
|
| Time to Fly! | Successfully perform a Top Rope move with a Risk Taker during a match | Silver
|
| Titanic | Complete every Challenge in the Mike Iceberg Tier | Bronze
|
| Too Strong | Win a 2 out of 3 Falls Match without conceding a fall | Silver
|
| Villain | Perform an Illegal move as any Heel wrestler during a match | Bronze
|
| Yes! Yes! Yes! | Earn 1,000,000 Coins | Bronze
|
| You! | Activate a Bulk Up as any Face character during a match | Bronze
|