| Character | How to unlock
|
|---|
| Drew McIntyre | Win the Fantasy Warfare Match with him against Roddy Piper
|
| Eddie Guerrero | Win the Fantasy Warfare Match with him against Rey Mysterio Jr.
|
| Edge | Win the Fantasy Warfare Match with him against Bret Hart
|
| Jack Swagger | Win the Fantasy Warfare Match with him against Sgt. Slaughter
|
| Jimmy Snuka | Win the Fantasy Warfare Match with him against Kane
|
| Kane | Win the Fantasy Warfare Match with him against Jimmy Snuka
|
| Mr. Perfect | Win the Fantasy Warfare Match with him against The Miz
|
| Sgt. Slaughter | Win the Fantasy Warfare Match with him against Jack Swagger
|
| Shawn Micheals | Win the Fantasy Warfare Match with him against The Undertaker
|
| The Miz | Win the Fantasy Warfare Match with him against Mr. Perfect
|