| Achievement | How to unlock
|
|---|
| A Fistful of Cutlets (26) | (Secret)
|
| A Real Underdog (13) | Buy a dark horse
|
| Contributing to the Delinquency of a Miner (30) | Finish the game with Crazy Pete
|
| Emperormaker (27) | (Secret)
|
| Horse Senseless (15) | Buy a crazy horse
|
| I Love the Way You Shoot (19) | (Secret)
|
| In a Row? (12) | Discover 37 map locations out West
|
| KUZPA HOPA (17) | (Secret)
|
| Looking a Ghost Horse in the Mouth (15) | Buy a pale horse
|
| Meat Mystery (24) | (Secret)
|
| No Country for Old Gods (22) | (Secret)
|
| Our Daily Bread (15) | Solve all of Breadwood's problems
|
| The Blackest Hat (29) | (Secret)
|
| The Hard Way (35) | Finish the game with the Hard Hat
|
| The Really Hard Way (37) | Finish the game with the Hard Hat in a single game day
|
| The Terrible Secret of Cotton Candy (25) | (Secret)
|
| Three Bridges Too Far (42) | Build three kinds of bridges (over three playthroughs)
|
| Under Pressure (27) | (Secret)
|
| WANTED: Alive (22) | Fully populate the Dirtwater jail
|
| WANTED: Dead (25) | Fully populate the Dirtwater morgue
|
| What's Up, Doc? (22) | (Secret)
|
| Won't You Come Out Tonight (22) | (Secret)
|
| Yes! Yes! To Finishing! (32) | (Secret)
|